Comments on: Ripping Off A Zillionaire

By: The Centaur

The Centaur — Tue, 10 Oct 2006 16:43:48 +0000

Anubis,

Thanks for defending my honor.

If only this was the 1700′s and it was socially acceptable to challenge Bungie to a duel.

The sad thing is, I would have gladly let Bungie just publish my original article for free… just to get the exposure.

Oh well, I’ve abandoned hope of anything coming of this, just wanted to vent a little to Zillionaire Nation.

By: St LcL Anubis

St LcL Anubis — Tue, 10 Oct 2006 05:48:14 +0000

Seriously, when I read the post on Bungie I sent the author a message giving him a direct link to your post and asked him if he had seen it. I told him your post was better and had a million more comments extended on the end. Until now I had hoped for a response asknowledgeing your talents and humor. Now I have lost faith in the Public Relations depatment of Bungie. Unfortunaly i am addicted to Halo, Halo 2, and can’t wait for Halo Wars/ Halo 3.

By: Booth

Booth — Mon, 02 Oct 2006 03:11:38 +0000

I’ve heard of journalists getting canned for ripping off less than this. Like Solo said, take it as a compliment on your writing.

By: el gato gordo

el gato gordo — Sun, 01 Oct 2006 22:34:42 +0000

Since imitation is the higest form of flattery, take it as a token that the person who they hired had to go to the extent of making a poor copy of another’s intelluctual property to keep his job. MS is all about taking from others and I think it follows that bungie follows the same reaction type content instead of proactive creativity. Fuck the lot of ‘em.

By: Krusty

Krusty — Sat, 30 Sep 2006 15:11:17 +0000

My god man how did you not call them with every profanity in the book. I say we march on their corporate office and find this cabin boy . I will hold him down while you give him a lecture on the finer points of stealing something cool and turning it into crap. I guess he is the expert. Tha sucks dude. I didn’t enjoy any of his descriptions. I just don;t get how you can take something that funny and ruin that bad. You should write his boss a letter asking him for royalties and to see if they need more content yet. I always had my suspicisions about bungie.

By: solo

solo — Fri, 29 Sep 2006 18:34:50 +0000

i feel you, but this is actually a good thing. this legitimizes your writing. don’t worry about it centaur, take it as a compliment. it’s every artist’s rite of passage to get ripped off of an idea. good job. just think, 30 years from now when you’re sitting in a diner and you over hear a kid talking about online personalities, you’ll be able to say, “hey, i thought of that idea.” and the kids will say, yea right old man. that’s sweet if you think about it.

By: The Centaur

The Centaur — Fri, 29 Sep 2006 17:36:23 +0000

Thanks for the support gentlemen.

Part of me wanted to shrug it off and not even post this. Of course, that would entail taking the high road in this matter.

And for those that know me, I rarely take the high road, as it is mostly uphill.

By: The Captive Lion

The Captive Lion — Fri, 29 Sep 2006 17:18:48 +0000

It’s funny because I read posts about web designers getting ripped off all the time. Someone usually copies most of the look and feel but changes 10-20% of it using poorly designed graphics, bad typography choices, and other hacks, drastically reducing its appeal and quality.

This is almost the exact same thing but with a blog post. They took the concept (good) but butchered the delivery (in my opinion) to play it safe, appeal to an infantile audience, or simply because of lack of talent.

I’m glad you decided to share this because it highlights how Bungie (a company most of us want to like) is really dropping the ball in respect to the content on their website and the crap they let fly on Xbox Live. The gaming audience is getting older, smarter, and more mature. I read their article and went to the forum to see the discussion it generated… let’s just say it made the swarm of goons that hit our site after your post was on collegehumor.com look like the 2006 graduating class at MIT.

BTW, did you notice the author’s signature is “Bungie.net Cabin Boy?” How’s that for a job title?

By: Matt Brett

Matt Brett — Fri, 29 Sep 2006 13:48:06 +0000

Yikes. Does it hurt when you get kicked in the teeth? That’s how I would take this, if I were in your position.

I highly doubt you will get any sort of response from them. There is a forum discussion going on about the article, though. 11 pages so far – needless to say, I haven’t paged through them but it would be great if someone brought this up there.

By: Omar

Omar — Fri, 29 Sep 2006 03:55:55 +0000

Eerily similar man.

That just sucks. I wonder if Bungie is going to respond to this, and I hope they do because I love Bungie.